I liked Peter and Mary Jane as a couple, and I wish that Quesada had been wise enough to leave well enough alone and not retcon their marriage out of existence. I even made another post about it
here and wrote about what I once said to Joe Quesada on the subject at a panel I attended
here. So let me make that clear right off the bat; just because I think Quesada might have a point about one thing does not mean that I think he was right to break up a marriage that had lasted twenty years.
However, yesterday I went to Fan Expo and took advantage of the fact that I was able to buy back issues that were decades old for literally cheaper than a current issue of anything. And we're not talking about shitty or long-cancelled stuff either; pretty much every single issue of
Amazing Spider-Man at one vendor I visited was a dollar an issue, and at another one I visited it was three dollars an issue. I could have picked up one of the issues that comprised the historic "Kraven's Last Hunt" story arc if I hadn't already bought the trade of that back when I was in high school.
Anyhoo, while flipping through the bin I saw an issue of ASM that said on the cover: "Peter Parker Asks The BIG Question!" And it showed Peter and MJ on the cover, and she looked really surprised. And this issue was from 1987. Didn't take a rocket scientist to figure out what question he was going to ask her. Awesome! I'd never seen, let alone read, this story before, so I bought it, along with the two issues that came after it. (The issue that followed those was that part of the Kraven story mentioned in the previous paragraph, and I knew that they had gotten hitched by the time that took place.)
ASM #290 is written by David Michelinie, who is one of the best writers I'm familiar with, and pencilled by John Romita Jr., who is one of the best pencillers I'm familiar with. That was a great creative team, and the story in ASM did not disappoint. I thought about including a summary of that, but I think that would be too much of a digression. Suffice to say that this story starts out with Peter considering the state of his life, and concluding that he's happy but nevertheless feels that there's something missing. During the course of the story, he pays a visit to Mary Jane's apartment and has a little talk with her. Now here's the thing: while reading that scene, there was a moment where I thought "Hmm, they're not quite acting like two people who are dating. Two people who are good friends and care about one another, definitely, but there's not really any romance here."
Fast forward to the end of the issue, when Peter goes back to her apartment. MJ's getting ready to take a trip, and she's telling Peter that she's really too busy to talk right now. Peter's trying to tell her that this is really important. Finally he gets it out: "Will you marry me?"
(That was on the last page of the issue, btw, along with "NEXT ISSUE: THE ANSWER!" So it's a damn good thing I bought the next issue!)
Okay, so what's Mary Jane's initial answer? Here is a transcript of the start of the next issue...
CAPTION: Several seconds ago, Peter Parker asked Mary Jane Watson to marry him. The young lady's immediate response had been a widening of the eyes and a slow drop of a startled jaw. Now, that initial reaction is followed by a tender and heartfelt...
MARY JANE: NO!
PETER: You mean you don't want to marry me? Is it because I'm Spider-Man--?
MARY JANE: No! I--I mean, I don't know! Like they say in the movies, Tiger, isn't this kind of sudden? I--I thought we were just friends!
PETER: We've been more than friends for a long time, MJ, and we both know it. I just felt it was time to get that out in the open. And after the way you helped me sort out my life this morning, I thought we should--
MARY JANE: That's, um, real sweet, Peter, but I can't talk about it now!And she goes on to explain that she has to get going because she has to see her sister in Pittsburgh, although she's intentionally vague about the reason, and after another minute or two she's out the door and on her way to the airport.
THAT is why I think Quesada may have had a point if one of his arguments was that the marriage in 1987 was rushed or forced.*
All these years, I had just assumed that Peter and MJ had been in a relationship before he popped the question. Now, the fact of the matter is that they had dated before this, and he even proposed to her once before this, but they eventually broke up and when he made that first proposal she turned it down and didn't change her mind.
If you think that Peter and Mary Jane make a good couple, as I do, the [i]logical[/i] thing to do would be to have them get together, go out for at least six issues (six months real world time), and then have Peter propose. (Or have MJ propose, if you like.) That would be realistic. This isn't. I mean, I guess sometimes something like that happens, but not very often, right?
I've read the whole story, at the end of which MJ decides that she wants to marry Peter after all. The wedding itself takes place in the ASM Annual as it turns out, which I'll have to get some other time.
As I said, this isn't a bad story by any means; I don't think that I've ever read a bad story by Michelinie. But it seems like there was executive meddling here, like Jim Shooter (the editor-in-chief at the time) was telling Michelinie behind the scenes that he wanted those two together ASAP.
*His objections to Peter being married at all, or to being married to MJ, are not what I consider good arguments against the marriage. Clark Kent and Lois Lane got married. Reed Richards and Susan Storm got married. Scott Summers and Jean Grey got married. There's no reason why Peter Parker shouldn't get married as he grows older. And as for being married to MJ...well, as Mary Jane herself tells her sister later on in the story, people grow and change over time. I could understand if people had a problem with her as a character--and as a potential mate for Pete--back when she seemed to be a ditz or when she was treating poor Harry Osborn like crap for no apparent reason, but by the time of Michelinie's run on the book in 1987 she had changed. She wasn't ditzy or bitchy any more. She was beautiful both inside and out. Peter could not have picked anybody better.